Instinct vs. Rawbble / Bixbi: Who Wins? [2025]

iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

In this article, we compare Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi Dog Food, focusing on key aspects such as ingredients, ingredient quality, protein content, price and value, and their recall history. Our objective is to provide a straightforward analysis to help pet owners decide between these two notable dog food brands.

Instinct Vs. Rawbble/Bixbi: An In-Depth Ingredient Comparison

When comparing dog food brands, the quality and type of ingredients used are among the most crucial factors for pet owners. In this detailed comparison, we’ll analyze the ingredients of Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi, two prominent brands in the pet food market, discussing the pros and cons of each.

Instinct Dog Food Ingredients Pros:

1. High-Quality Protein Sources: Instinct often uses real meats like cage-free chicken or grass-fed beef as their primary ingredient, providing essential amino acids for muscle development and energy.
2. Natural and Raw Ingredients: The brand emphasizes raw ingredients, which are believed to offer higher nutritional value by preserving more natural nutrients.
3. Fruits and Vegetables Inclusion: Instinct incorporates a variety of fruits and vegetables, such as carrots and apples, which provide natural sources of vitamins, minerals, and fiber for digestive health.
4. Grain-Free Options: For dogs with grain sensitivities, Instinct offers several grain-free formulas, reducing the risk of allergies and digestive issues.

Instinct Dog Food Ingredients Cons:

1. Higher Price Range: The premium quality of the ingredients and specialized manufacturing processes lead to a higher price point for Instinct products.
2. Raw Diet Concerns: Raw diets can be controversial due to potential risks of bacterial contamination and nutritional imbalances if not formulated correctly.
3. Limited Customization: Instinct’s product range, while diverse, may not offer as much customization for specific dietary needs compared to some other brands.

Rawbble/Bixbi Dog Food Ingredients Pros:

1. Quality Protein Sources: Rawbble/Bixbi focuses on high-quality proteins, including USDA-inspected meats. This ensures a rich source of protein that is crucial for a dog’s health and well-being.
2. Whole Food Ingredients: They emphasize whole food ingredients, avoiding fillers and artificial additives, which can be beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies.
3. Balanced Nutrient Profile: Rawbble/Bixbi formulates their products to provide a balanced nutrient profile, including a good balance of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals.
4. Transparency in Sourcing: They are known for their transparency in ingredient sourcing, reassuring pet owners about the quality and safety of the food.

Rawbble/Bixbi Dog Food Ingredients Cons:

1. Cost Factor: Similar to Instinct, Rawbble/Bixbi’s high-quality ingredients and ethical sourcing practices can make their products more expensive than average dog food options.
2. Limited Grain-Inclusive Options: While they offer grain-free products, their range of grain-inclusive options might be limited, which might not suit all dietary preferences.
3. Specific Dietary Formulas: While Rawbble/Bixbi offers high-quality general dog food, they may have fewer options for specific dietary needs, such as low-protein diets or diets for medical conditions.

Ingredient Quality and Variety Comparison

Both Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi place a strong emphasis on high-quality, natural ingredients. Instinct’s focus leans more towards raw, less-processed ingredients, which aligns with a philosophy of feeding dogs a diet closer to what they would consume in the wild. Rawbble/Bixbi, meanwhile, stresses the importance of whole food ingredients and transparency in sourcing, ensuring a high standard of quality and safety.

Protein Content and Sources

The primary protein sources in Instinct’s products are real meats, often raw or minimally processed. This approach is beneficial for dogs who thrive on high-protein diets. Rawbble/Bixbi also ensures high-quality protein sources but places more emphasis on USDA-inspected meats, which guarantees a standard of quality and safety.

Suitability for Different Dogs

Instinct’s variety, including raw and grain-free options, caters to a broad range of dietary preferences and needs. Their products are suitable for dogs at all life stages and with various dietary requirements. Rawbble/Bixbi, with their focus on whole food ingredients and balanced nutrition, also caters to a wide range of dogs, but their offerings might be more limited for dogs with very specific dietary restrictions.

Catering to Dietary Needs and Sensitivities

Instinct offers specific formulas for different dietary needs, such as limited ingredient diets for sensitivities and allergies. Rawbble/Bixbi, with their whole food approach and avoidance of fillers and artificial additives, can be a good choice for dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies. However, their range may not be as extensive as some other brands in addressing unique dietary needs.

Nutritional Balance and Variety

Both brands provide a good balance of nutrients in their formulas. Instinct’s approach to raw nutrition ensures a diet rich in proteins and natural vitamins, while Rawbble/Bixbi’s balanced nutrient profile, emphasizing whole foods, provides a comprehensive diet suitable for the overall health and well-being of dogs.

In conclusion, Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi both offer high-quality, nutritious ingredients in their dog food products. The choice between the two should be based on a dog’s specific dietary needs, preferences, and any sensitivities, considering the pros and cons of each brand’s ingredient philosophy and formulation.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Instinct Vs. Rawbble/Bixbi

Recalls & Lawsuits: Instinct Vs. Rawbble/Bixbi

In the world of pet food, the history of recalls and lawsuits can significantly influence a brand’s reputation and consumer trust. Examining the recall and lawsuit histories of Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi provides valuable insight into their commitment to product safety and quality standards.

Instinct Dog Food Recalls and Lawsuits

Instinct, a brand known for its focus on raw and natural ingredients, has experienced a relatively clean track record with minimal recalls. One of the notable recalls occurred in March 2016, when Instinct recalled a specific lot of its Raw Chicken Formula for dogs due to concerns about potential salmonella contamination. This precautionary recall was issued after the company identified the risk through its own testing procedures. The swift action taken by Instinct in this instance demonstrated their responsiveness and commitment to consumer safety.

In terms of legal challenges, Instinct has not faced any major lawsuits that question the safety or quality of their products. This absence of significant legal issues suggests a strong adherence to quality control and safety protocols in their manufacturing processes.

Rawbble/Bixbi Dog Food Recalls and Lawsuits

Rawbble/Bixbi, a brand that emphasizes whole food ingredients and quality protein sources, has also maintained a commendable safety record. To date, there have been no significant recalls associated with Rawbble/Bixbi dog food products. This clean history is indicative of their strict quality control measures and their commitment to providing safe, high-quality pet food.

Similarly, Rawbble/Bixbi has not been involved in major lawsuits regarding the safety or health implications of their products. This lack of legal issues further emphasizes their reputation for maintaining high standards in the production and formulation of their dog food.

Analysis of Safety Protocols and Quality Assurance

Both Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi have demonstrated a commitment to maintaining high safety standards in their products. Instinct’s proactive response to potential safety issues, as seen in their 2016 recall, reflects their dedication to consumer and pet safety. Rawbble/Bixbi’s lack of recalls or major legal issues is a testament to their effective safety measures and stringent quality control practices.

It is important to note that recalls in the pet food industry, while concerning, are not uncommon and can be indicative of a company’s vigilance in monitoring and ensuring the quality of its products. The fact that both Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi have either limited or no recalls, coupled with the absence of significant lawsuits, speaks to their reliability and trustworthiness as pet food brands.

In summary, the recall and lawsuit histories of Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi are indicative of their commitment to quality and safety. Instinct’s minimal recalls and lack of major lawsuits, along with Rawbble/Bixbi’s clean safety record, should provide reassurance to pet owners about the reliability of these brands. When choosing between Instinct and Rawbble/Bixbi, their recall and legal histories are crucial factors to consider, alongside other elements like ingredient quality, nutritional value, and price.

Compare Pricing & Discounts: Instinct Vs. Rawbble/Bixbi

Our Verdict -Instinct Vs. Rawbble/Bixbi: Who Wins?